My Secure Advantage

Exploring Traditional vs. Online Investing

The world of investing has changed a lot over the years.  There are still many investors who want to trade stocks the way they may have done for a long time: through a stockbroker.
By MSA Staff

The world of investing has changed a lot over the years.  There are still many investors who want to trade stocks the way they may have done for a long time: through a stockbroker.  But there is now a new generation connected to their smartphones, and they expect buying and selling stock to be a click away, just the way they find restaurants or clothes or book a vacation.  Let’s explore both traditional and online investing, so you can get a better idea of what may best fit your needs.

Traditional Investing

Personal Touch

When we say traditional, we mean buying and selling stocks and other investments (like mutual funds and ETFs) by using a stockbroker.

If you work with a stockbroker, hopefully, they check in with you often to see how life is going, and they can talk to you about adjusting your portfolio accordingly.  Maybe you were laid off or had a new child, or you or one of your loved ones are sick.  Any of these life events may cause you to readjust your portfolio.  It may be worth it to you to have a real person with whom to talk this all through and who can give you advice and counsel and even mentor you through what is going on.

Your broker can be a valuable resource because they probably have access to research and a professional understanding of the market.  It’s not their responsibility to pick up the phone to give you a heads-up, but they often will. All of these personal touches are not necessarily available online.

Your Goals

Personal stockbrokers offer just that – personal service. If they are doing their job, they should know you and have laid out your financial goals centered around your life and therefore have matched your portfolio with those goals.  They also should have discussed your risk tolerance, as well.

Do Your Research

If you are in the process of researching brokers, then ask them questions, use the FINRA BrokerCheck, and consider talking with a Money Coach for tools to help you make an informed decision – but more on that later.

Online Investing

How to Take Control

Online investing can be done via your computer or your smartphone.  This type of investing gives you a chance to build your own portfolio.  You may be able to execute buying and selling with a click. The biggest advantage is convenience.  You can perform transactions from nearly anywhere and monitor your investments in real-time.  It is also easy to make mistakes that can be costly if you don’t know what you’re doing.


Safety is always a concern, and while nothing can guarantee full safety, most online trading sites use high-end encryption.  Before settling on a particular investing platform, double-check that it has proper security protocols in place.


Online investing may offer state-of-the-art research for no additional charges, but you have to read it and draw out the information that is of interest to you. More of this burden or responsibility will be on you than if you were working with a stockbroker who does the research for you.

Lower Fees

Online investing platforms tend to charge lower fees than a broker will charge, but compare and do your research.  Additionally, you are the one that has to police scams and risky investments.

Can be Addictive

One of the things to consider when using online investing is exactly the ease of doing it.  Buying and selling stock is a click away.  It’s fun, and fun may get you in trouble. Video games are fun; online gambling is fun…and these can be addictive.  Understand your own personality and decide whether this is a good fit for you.

Next Steps – Money Coaching

Take the first step towards building a better financial future by working with a Money Coach at MSA. Money Coaches are educators dedicated to helping you improve your financial well-being. They don’t offer advice, earn commissions, or sell products. MSA coaches can assess your investing risk tolerance and help you create a budget to allocate savings toward investing. Working with a Money Coach can be a game changer for investing, regardless of whether you invest on your own or work with a stockbroker. Call and start working with your own personal Money Coach today!

About the Author

Neale Godfrey is a New York Times #1 Best Selling Author of 27 books on empowering families (and their kids) to take charge of their financial lives.

Information provided in this article is for informational purposes only and is not intended to offer specific personalized investment, financial planning, tax, legal, or accounting advice.  We recommend that you consult an attorney, tax advisor, or accountant regarding your unique circumstances. This content is for informational purposes only and does not guarantee eligibility for the program or its services. My Secure Advantage, Inc. or any of its representatives do not endorse any of the websites or company names listed here.

Your investments in the stock market are subject to a variety of risks, including the potential loss of your original investment. Diversification and asset allocation do not guarantee a profit or protect you from loss. Working with an investment professional does not guarantee a profit or protect you from loss.  No investment professional, regardless of their credentials or level of experience, can assure that you will meet your investment goals.

Facebook ShareTweetReddit shareLinkedIn shareEmail share

More Like This


You don’t think twice about protecting your shiny car, and in most states, you don’t have a say (quite frankly).  But there is another type of insurance that people should consider, and many employers, banks, and institutions are considering making it mandatory as well.  Let’s take a look at why…. Car Insurance $164.2 billion in […]

Fashion & Style

Want to be a smart shopper and spend less? Master these tips and you could be saving money in no time. Make a spending plan.  Ultimately, you shouldn’t spend money unless it’s in the budget, so buy all necessary purchases before you think about getting any luxury items. Online shopping.  Research multiple retailers’ pricing, product […]

Tips & Tricks

Investing for the first time may seem daunting. All of those terms seem so confusing. Here are some reminders and tips to ease the uncertainty. The biggest incentive is that you could actually have that million dollars you want for your retirement if you started to invest early. But it’s never too late. The stock […]

Tips & Tricks

Investing may seem like a complicated process requiring lots of time, energy and knowledge. After all, looking at those acronyms, arrows, colors and numbers can be pretty intimidating for a new investor. The good news is that there are plenty of ways to invest. In fact, you’re probably already an investor, whether you know it […]